Learning Styles: What the 2008 Review and Later Papers Found

Key Points

  • A 2008 review by Pashler, McDaniel, Rohrer and Bjork concluded that there was no adequate evidence base to justify incorporating learning-styles assessments into general educational practice.
  • The review said a credible test needs students grouped by style, randomly assigned to different teaching methods and given the same final test, and it found virtually no evidence for the interaction pattern it judged a precondition for validating learning-styles instruction.
  • The same review said it would be an error to conclude that all possible versions of learning styles have been tested and found wanting, because many have not been tested.
  • A 2017 survey of 114 UK academics by Newton and Miah found 58 percent general belief in the use of learning styles and 33 percent reporting actual use.

Published .

The Long Room of the Old Library at Trinity College Dublin, a long barrel-vaulted hall with two-storey wooden bookcases full of old books on both sides, white marble busts along the aisle and a glass display case on the polished floor.
The Long Room of the Old Library at Trinity College Dublin, shown as an example of a library reading space. Photo: Diliff, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons, resized, photo source.

A 2008 review by Pashler, McDaniel, Rohrer and Bjork concluded that there was no adequate evidence base to justify incorporating learning-styles assessments into general educational practice1. The idea behind those assessments is that people differ in which mode of instruction works best for them. Later papers report continued belief in the idea and its presence in the research literature, and the sections below follow what each of these papers reported. Every source here is an abstract record, because the full texts were not opened.

What the learning-styles claim says

The review describes learning styles as the concept that individuals differ in what mode of instruction or study is most effective for them, with proponents holding that optimal instruction requires diagnosing a learner's style and tailoring teaching to it1. Assessments typically ask people to evaluate what sort of information presentation they prefer, such as words, pictures or speech, or what kind of mental activity they find most engaging1.

The most common, but not the only, hypothesis is the meshing hypothesis, under which instruction works best when it comes in a format that matches the learner's preference, such as emphasizing visual presentation for a visual learner1. The authors wrote that there is a thriving industry of learning-styles tests and guidebooks for teachers, and that many organizations offer workshops built around the concept1.

The test the 2008 review set

The authors were charged with determining whether these practices are supported by scientific evidence. They concluded that a credible validation needs students divided into groups by learning style, students in each group randomly assigned to one of several instructional methods, and a final test that is the same for everyone1.

The result also has to show a specific interaction: students with one learning style do best with one instructional method, while students with a different style do best with a different one1.

What the review found

The authors found ample evidence that children and adults, when asked, express preferences about how they want information presented, and plentiful evidence that people differ in the degree to which they have some fairly specific aptitudes for different kinds of thinking1. They found virtually no evidence for the interaction pattern they judged to be a precondition, and very few experiments used a method capable of testing learning styles in education. Several of those that did reported results that flatly contradict the meshing hypothesis1.

The review also said it would be an error to conclude that all possible versions of learning styles have been tested and found wanting, because many have simply not been tested1.

Belief after 2008

In a 2015 perspective article in Frontiers in Psychology, Philip Newton analyzed recent papers listed in the ERIC and PubMed databases and reported that 89 percent implicitly or directly endorse the use of learning styles in higher education, with the VAK and Kolb inventories dominating them2.

A 2017 survey of 114 academics in UK higher education by Newton and Miah found general belief in the use of learning styles at 58 percent, lower than in similar earlier surveys, while 33 percent reported actually using them3. Thirty-two percent said they would continue to use learning styles even after being presented with the lack of an evidence base3.

In a 2021 perspective article, Newton, Najabat-Lattif, Santiago and Salvi looked at recent papers on learning styles from health professions education and found that 91 percent of 112 were based on the premise that learning styles are a useful approach4.

Where this leaves the idea

The 2008 review drew a line between two things. People do report preferences, and they do differ in some aptitudes, but the review found virtually no evidence for the specific pattern that would show matching teaching to a style improves results. The review also left room for versions that have not been tested. The 2017 survey found belief (58 percent) higher than reported use (33 percent). In their abstract, Newton and Miah wrote that the idea has been repeatedly tested and that there is currently no evidence to support it3. This article describes published findings from abstracts and gives no guidance for any student, teacher or school.

Trivia

  1. According to the 2008 review, what does the meshing hypothesis say? Instruction works best when its format matches the learner's preference1.
  2. In what year did Pashler, McDaniel, Rohrer and Bjork publish their review in Psychological Science in the Public Interest? 20081.
  3. How many UK academics did Newton and Miah survey? 1143.
  4. In that survey, what percent of respondents reported actually using learning styles? 33 percent3.
  5. Which two inventories dominated the papers Newton analyzed in 2015? VAK and Kolb2.

Sources

  1. Pashler, McDaniel, Rohrer and Bjork, Learning Styles: Concepts and Evidence, Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 2008 (abstract record). Accessed October 27, 2026.
  2. Newton, The Learning Styles Myth is Thriving in Higher Education, Frontiers in Psychology, 2015 (abstract record). Accessed October 27, 2026.
  3. Newton and Miah, Evidence-Based Higher Education - Is the Learning Styles 'Myth' Important?, Frontiers in Psychology, 2017 (abstract record). Accessed October 27, 2026.
  4. Newton, Najabat-Lattif, Santiago and Salvi, The Learning Styles Neuromyth Is Still Thriving in Medical Education, Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 2021 (abstract record). Accessed October 27, 2026.