The Mandela Effect: How Strangers End Up With the Same False Memory
Key Points
- The Mandela effect is a popular name for shared false memories, and paranormal researcher Fiona Broome coined the term.
- Examples of shared misremembered details include a monocle on Mr. Monopoly, the spelling Berenstein Bears and the line "Luke, I am your father."
- A 2022 study in Psychological Science found that certain images produce consistent, specific false memories, with no attentional or visual differences driving them.
- The 2022 study does not explain why it happens, and it found the errors persist even though most of what people see is the correct version.

Mr. Monopoly has no monocle, the children's books are the Berenstain Bears, and Darth Vader never says "Luke, I am your father." Yet these wrong versions turn up in the same form from person to person. Researchers have found that some false memories are shared and specific across people4, and the pattern has a popular name, the Mandela effect. Here is where the name came from, what experiments have found, and what is still unexplained.
Where the name came from
The term was coined by paranormal researcher Fiona Broome1, who reported vivid memories of news coverage of Nelson Mandela dying in prison in the 1980s. He actually died in 2013, after his release and after serving as President of South Africa from 1994 to 1999. Broome reported that hundreds of other people had written about having the same memory, and she speculated that it came from movement between parallel realities.
A more ordinary explanation offered for the Mandela memory is that people confused him with Steve Biko1, another South African anti-apartheid activist, who did die in prison, in 1977.
The famous examples
The list of shared misremembered details includes The Berenstain Bears spelled "Berenstein", Looney Tunes spelled "Looney Toons", a cornucopia in the Fruit of the Loom logo, and Mr. Monopoly wearing a monocle1. In The Empire Strikes Back, Vader's actual line to Luke is "No, I am your father"1.
What researchers have tested
A 2009 study looked at the clock at Bologna's railway station. A 1980 bomb stopped it at 10.25, but it was repaired and worked normally for 16 years3, until it broke in 1996 and its hands were left at 10.25 in remembrance. Of the 173 participants who knew the clock is now stopped, 160, or 92%, said it had always been broken3, and 127 said they had always seen it at 10.25, including all 21 railway employees. The study was published by Stefania de Vito, Roberto Cubelli and Sergio Della Sala in Cortex in 20092, under the title "Collective representations elicit widespread individual false memories."
In 2022, Deepasri Prasad and Wilma Bainbridge of the University of Chicago published experiments on what they called the visual Mandela effect4 in Psychological Science, writing that it had not yet been empirically quantified or tested. In a first experiment, with 100 adults, certain images from popular iconography produced consistent, specific false memories. A second, with 60 adults and eye-tracking-like methods, found no attentional or visual differences that drive it. A third found no clear difference in people's natural visual experience of these images. In a fourth, with 50 adults, the same errors appeared spontaneously when people recalled the images.
What is still unexplained
The 2022 study found the effect is consistent and measurable for some images, but it does not explain why. Its authors concluded that people make the same false-memory error for certain images despite the majority of visual experience being the canonical image4. Since most of what people see is the correct version, that argues against the simplest explanation, that people had seen the wrong version more often.
Trivia
- Who coined the term Mandela effect? Fiona Broome, a paranormal researcher1.
- In what year did Nelson Mandela actually die? 20131.
- What is Mr. Monopoly falsely remembered wearing? A monocle4.
- What is Darth Vader's actual line? "No, I am your father"1.
- What share of participants who knew the Bologna clock is stopped said it had always been broken? 92%, or 160 of 1733.
- How many adults took part in the first 2022 visual Mandela effect experiment? 1004.
Sources
- False memory, Wikipedia. Accessed October 21, 2026.
- Stefania de Vito, Roberto Cubelli and Sergio Della Sala, Collective representations elicit widespread individual false memories, Cortex 45(5): 686 to 687 (2009), PubMed record. Accessed October 21, 2026.
- Vaughan Bell, Symbol of remembrance triggers mass false memory, Mind Hacks (March 31, 2009). Accessed October 21, 2026.
- Deepasri Prasad and Wilma A. Bainbridge, The Visual Mandela Effect as Evidence for Shared and Specific False Memories Across People, Psychological Science 33(12): 1971 to 1988 (2022), PubMed record. Accessed October 21, 2026.